Vuvuzelas: What’s the Best Response?

One by one, Premiership clubs in England are banning the vuvuzela (that really annoying instrument played incessantly at the World Cup).  But the Premier League authorities won’t simply impose a blanket ban and instead are leaving the decision up to the individual clubs.

Which begs the question: What is the best response for, say, Blackpool, recently promoted to the Premiership?  The top clubs have banned them already (Spurs are the latest), the clubs with large stadia and many fans.  Blackpool is a much smaller club with a smaller stadium and likely less noise with which to intimidate visiting teams.  Wigan might be asking similar questions – could their stadium become a less pleasant place to visit for other teams if their fans are busy blowing vuvuzelas all afternoon?

I guess this is something akin to a nice empirical example of a game – the action is (ban, don’t ban), the players are all the Premiership clubs, they don’t move simultaneously though, and the pay-off isn’t clear yet likely dependent on what the other clubs do.  Now the big clubs have imposed bans, their stadia will remain quiet, peaceful places – but the homes of strong teams.  Will the bans mean players at those clubs are less used to the drone of vuvuzelas and hence the pay-off of allowing them to blown means more points from home games this season?

Assuming bans aren’t imposed by all clubs, it certainly gives some variation upon which to carry out some analysis.  The absence of a counter-factual however (how would Blackpool have done if we repeated the season and they did/didn’t impose the ban) complicates things, but assuming a club that was in the Premiership last season allows vuvuzelas, this could be somewhat akin to a natural experiment – the players certainly didn’t sign for any particular club to avoid vuvuzelas or because they like them…


One Response to Vuvuzelas: What’s the Best Response?


    Manchester City and Stoke are the only two clubs to have allowed the Vuvuzelas in their stadiums. While, many others had brains to realize the harm to public safety provided by the vuvuzelas, including not being able to hear emergecy announcements in the stadiums because of the 120 decibel volume of these horns. Here is a list of the stance of all Premier League clubs over the vuvuzela situatio

    Blackpool – ‘The club is disputing recent claims of encouraging the vuvuzelas and will discuss them in due course.’LOL

    Everton – Banned – ‘due to health and safety and complaints from fans after the World Cup.’

    Fulham – Banned – ‘Other clubs banning, health and safety element also.’

    Liverpool – Banned – ‘health and safety risk.’

    Manchester City – Allowed – ‘no official policy against them, not an issue.’

    Stoke City – Allowed – ‘no plans to ban.’

    Sunderland – Banned – ‘policy against musical instruments.’

    Tottenham – Banned – ‘annoyance to fans.’

    West Ham – Banned – ‘policy against musical instruments.’

    Come my Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: